Apollonius of Rhodes was a poet and scholar at Alexandria, the Greek capital of Ptolemaic Egypt, in the third century BC.1 He is remembered for one poem, the Argonautica: the voyage of Jason and the Argonauts to fetch the Golden Fleece. It is the only epic of the Hellenistic age (the age of the Greek kingdoms that followed Alexander the Great) that survives entire,2,3 and Roman poets, Virgil among them, took it as a model.1,4
A life pieced together from scraps
Almost nothing about him is certain.1 What we have are two short ancient Lives, copied at the end of the old notes on the poem in its oldest manuscript; an entry in the Suda, a Byzantine encyclopaedia of the tenth century; and a list of the Library's heads on a papyrus of the second century AD.1,5,6 The Suda calls him «Ἀπολλώνιοϲ, Ἀλεξανδρεὺϲ, ἐπῶν ποιητὴϲ, διατρίψαϲ ἐν Ῥόδῳ», “Apollonius, of Alexandria, an epic poet, who spent time in Rhodes” (our translation), and makes him the son of Silleus and a pupil of the poet Callimachus.7 The geographer Strabo agrees about his city: he and another scholar, “though Alexandrians, were called Rhodians”.8 But Athenaeus and Aelian call him «Ἀπολλώνιος ὁ Ῥόδιος ἢ Ναυκρατίτης», “Apollonius the Rhodian or Naucratian”, after Naucratis, a Greek town some 70 km south of Alexandria on the Nile.1,9,10 In ancient lives, “pupil” was often only a way of saying that one poet influenced another.1
Debated among scholars No ancient source gives the year of his birth, and modern guesses have run from 296 BC to as late as 235.1,5 The papyrus list names “Apollonius son of Silleus, of Alexandria, called the Rhodian, the disciple of Callimachus” as head of the Library, says that he taught the king, and makes Eratosthenes his successor; its beginning is lost, but Zenodotus is taken to have been head before him.1,6 The papyrus calls the king the “first”, which its translator takes as a slip for the third, Ptolemy III, who came to the throne in 247/246 BC.1,6 The Suda instead makes Apollonius the successor of Eratosthenes, which does not fit; a later librarian, also called Apollonius, may have caused the confusion.1,7
Rhodes, and a famous quarrel
Ancient tradition / legend The Lives tell a story. While still young, Apollonius recited the Argonautica at Alexandria and it failed; ashamed, he left for Rhodes, polished the poem, recited it again to great acclaim, and was made a citizen; the first Life says that he then called himself a Rhodian in the poem's title, the second that he is called the Rhodian because he made his home and taught there. “Some say”, the second Life adds, that he came back to Alexandria, was put in charge of the libraries, and was buried next to Callimachus.5,6 Ancient biographers liked to send poets into exile, and the scholar Mary Lefkowitz argues that these tales were probably invented to explain why there were two editions of the poem; the name “of Rhodes” may only mean that he wrote a poem about the island.1
Debated among scholars Then there is the quarrel. The Suda's entry on Callimachus says that his lost poem Ibis was aimed «εἴϲ τινα Ἴβον, γενόμενον ἐχθρὸν τοῦ Καλλιμάχου· ἦν δὲ οὗτοϲ Ἀπολλώνιοϲ, ὁ γράψαϲ τὰ Ἀργοναυτικά», “at a certain Ibis, who had become Callimachus' enemy; this was Apollonius, who wrote the Argonautica” (our translation).11 An epigram under the name of “Apollonius the grammarian” mocks Callimachus and his Aetia (“Causes”): «Καλλίμαχος τὸ κάθαρμα, τὸ παίγνιον, ὁ ξύλινος νοῦς», “Callimachus the scum, the plaything, the wooden brain” (our translation).1,12 In 1912 George Mooney, whose Greek text the reader uses, wrote that their feud “stands out as the most bitter in the ancient world of letters”.5 Most scholars now think it has been greatly exaggerated, if it happened at all: both Lives stress the two poets' friendship, the Ibis was meant to be obscure, and the epigram may be by another Apollonius.1
A scholar's poem
Apollonius was also a leading student of Homer. He wrote the period's first scholarly study of Homer, criticising the editions of Zenodotus, and prose works on Archilochus and on problems in Hesiod are credited to him.1 Of his other poems, on the founding of cities such as Alexandria, Naucratis, Cnidus and Rhodes, only scraps survive.1 Athenaeus quotes a few lines from his Foundation of Naucratis, where a sailor called Pompilus, who tried to save a girl from Apollo, is turned into a fish.9
The Argonautica runs to four books and fewer than 6,000 lines, much shorter than Homer's epics.2 It opens with Apollo: «ἀρχόμενος σέο, Φοῖβε, παλαιγενέων κλέα φωτῶν μνήσομαι», “Beginning with you, Phoebus, I will recall the famous deeds of men born long ago” (our translation), the men who, at King Pelias' command, sailed the Argo «χρύσειον μετὰ κῶας», “after the golden fleece”.13 Book 1 gathers the crew and sets out; Book 2 brings them through the Clashing Rocks into the Black Sea and up the river Phasis in Colchis; in Book 3 the king's daughter Medea falls in love with Jason and helps him through his trials; Book 4 is the long, roundabout voyage home, by the Danube, Italy and the deserts of Libya.2,3 When he wrote it is disputed too: under Ptolemy II, or a generation later; one study of the stars the poem describes points to 238 BC.2,3
Reading Apollonius
He writes in Homer's language, but he is no mere copyist. He keeps old epic forms, using the old genitive ending -οιο even more freely than the Iliad, yet he coins new forms and stretches Homer's grammar in new directions.14 One scholar has called the poem “a kind of poetic dictionary of Homer”.1 He talks to the poets of his own day too: one line, «καὶ τὰ μὲν ὧς ἤμελλε μετὰ χρόνον ἐκτελέεσθαι», “And thus were those things to be accomplished in the course of time”, repeats a line of Callimachus' Aetia word for word.2,15
His Jason is no Achilles. He is a more human, less heroic leader, and the scholar Hermann Fränkel summed up the crew's repeated despair in one word, ἀμηχανία, “helplessness”.1,2,16 The heart of the poem is Medea. Book 3 begins by calling on Erato, the Muse of love poetry: «εἰ δʼ ἄγε νῦν, Ἐρατώ, παρά θʼ ἵστασο», “Come now, Erato, stand beside me” (our translation).2,17 Eros shoots her, and «βέλος δʼ ἐνεδαίετο κούρῃ νέρθεν ὑπὸ κραδίῃ, φλογὶ εἴκελον», “the arrow burned deep down in the girl's heart, like a flame” (our translation).18 That night, while sailors at sea look out at the Bear and Orion, travellers and gatekeepers long for sleep, and deep sleep wraps even a mother whose children have died, «ἀλλὰ μάλʼ οὐ Μήδειαν ἐπὶ γλυκερὸς λάβεν ὕπνος», “but sweet sleep did not take hold of Medea” (our translation), and her heart leaps like a sunbeam that dances about a house, thrown back from water just poured into a cauldron or a pail.19 The critic A. W. Bulloch judged that Apollonius seems to have been the first narrative poet to study “the pathology of love”.2
In Book 4 Medea lures her brother Apsyrtus into a trap and Jason kills him.2 Before he tells it, the poet turns on Love himself: «σχέτλιʼ Ἔρως, μέγα πῆμα, μέγα στύγος ἀνθρώποισιν», “Merciless Love, great misery, great horror for mankind” (our translation). At the moment of the killing Medea turns her eyes away and covers herself with her veil, «μὴ φόνον ἀθρήσειε κασιγνήτοιο τυπέντος», “so as not to see her brother struck down and killed” (our translation).16,20 The poem ends with a farewell to its heroes, «Ἵλατʼ ἀριστήων μακάρων γένος», “Be gracious, race of blessed heroes” (our translation), as they step ashore at Pagasae, where they set out.21,22
Why he matters
Ancient critics were cool. The author of the treatise On the Sublime, known as Longinus, granted that Apollonius was «ἄπτωτος», a wrestler's word for one who is never thrown, and so “faultless”, but asked: «ἆρ’ οὖν Ὅμηρος ἂν μᾶλλον ἢ Ἀπολλώνιος ἐθέλοις γενέσθαι;», “would you rather be Homer, then, or Apollonius?” (our translation).16,23 The Roman teacher Quintilian explained that the scholars' lists of classic poets left him out because they included no poets of their own day, but judged that “his work is by no means to be despised”.24
Roman poets read him closely. Varro of Atax, who died about 35 BC, put the Argonautica into Latin; Catullus imitated it constantly in his poem 64, and Virgil made it one of his models for the Aeneid.4,25,26 The Latin writer Macrobius claimed that Virgil had shaped “librum Aeneidos suae quartum totum paene”, “almost the whole fourth book of his Aeneid” (our translation), on Apollonius, giving Medea's passion for Jason to Dido.27 About AD 70 Valerius Flaccus began a new Latin Argonautica, a free imitation of the Greek and in places a translation.28 Long dismissed in modern times as a mere imitator of Homer, Apollonius has risen again in scholars' esteem.1