Theocritus was a Greek poet of the early third century BC, and the first poet of pastoral: the herdsmen who sing to one another in the shade, in the kind of poetry later called pastoral, begin with him.1,2 He came from Syracuse in Sicily, was born about 300 BC or a little earlier (Cholmeley put it at 310–308), and spent part of his life on the island of Cos in the Aegean and part at the court of King Ptolemy II in Alexandria.1,2,3 The date of his death is unknown.2
What little we know
Debated among scholars Almost nothing about his life comes from outside his own poems: a short notice in the Suda, a Byzantine encyclopaedia, an anonymous life copied before the poems in many manuscripts, and a few notes by ancient commentators. R. J. Cholmeley, whose edition is the Greek text in the reader, judged that these notices are “to a large extent merely inferences from the poet's own works”, and that they do not agree with one another.3 J. M. Edmonds, his Loeb translator of 1912, listed what the poems show and then admitted: “The rest—and that means much of the following account—is conjecture.”4
The Suda names his parents as Praxagoras and Philinna, “though others [say], of Simmichas”, calls him a Syracusan, and adds that some said he came from Cos and moved to Syracuse.5 The Suda's entry begins with a different Theocritus, an orator from the island of Chios,5 and an epigram that ancient editions carried with the poems, not written by Theocritus himself according to Cholmeley, makes the poet say: “The Chian is someone else; I, Theocritus, who wrote these poems, am one of the many people of Syracuse, son of Praxagoras and famous Philinna” (our translation).3,6 His own poems point to Sicily too: in Idyll 11 the one-eyed giant Polyphemus is «ὁ Κύκλωψ ὁ παρʼ ἁμῖν», “the Cyclops who lived among us” (our translation).2,7
Debated among scholars Idyll 7, the Harvest Feast, is set on Cos.2,3 Its narrator, whom his friends call Simichidas,2,8 says modestly that he does not yet win against the best: «οὔτε τὸν ἐσθλὸν Σικελίδαν νίκημι τὸν ἐκ Σάμω οὔτε Φιλητᾶν ἀείδων», “in singing I beat neither the good Sicelidas from Samos nor Philitas” (our translation).9 Philitas was the famous poet and scholar of Cos, and ancient commentators took Sicelidas to be the poet Asclepiades of Samos.2,3 The ancient life makes Theocritus a pupil of both; Cholmeley thought this seemed “merely an inference” from this very passage, though he found some support for it in the surviving lines of Philitas.3
Two poems give the only dates. Idyll 16 asks Hiero II, the new leader of Syracuse, to become the poet's patron; Idyll 17 praises Ptolemy II and his queen Arsinoe, who was also his sister.2,3 By the usual reckoning both belong between about 275 and 270 BC, though nineteenth-century scholars argued for later dates for Idyll 16.2,3 In Idyll 14 a man unlucky in love is told that Ptolemy is the best of paymasters, and advised to go and serve him as a soldier: «ᾇ τάχος εἰς Αἴγυπτον», “quick, off to Egypt!” (our translation).2,10
What survives
Under his name we have a book of poems called Idylls, a set of epigrams, and a riddle-poem called the Syrinx, and the reader has all three.11,12,13 The reader's edition counts thirty Idylls; Gow's counts thirty-one.11,14 The title comes from the Greek eidyllion, a diminutive of the word for “form”, so “little forms”; LSJ defines it as a “short, highly wrought descriptive poem, mostly on pastoral subjects”, citing it from the ancient notes on Theocritus.1,15
The book is much wider than the fame of its country poems suggests. There are mimes, little scenes of town life: in Idyll 2 Simaetha, deserted by her lover, tells her story to the moon, and in Idyll 15 two Syracusan housewives push through the crowds to the palace of King Ptolemy to see the festival of Adonis.2,16 There are poems of praise and hymns (16, 17, 22), short tales of heroes such as Hylas (13) and the infant Heracles (24), and poems in the Aeolic dialect and metre (28, 29 and 30, the last found only in 1864, in one late manuscript); Idyll 28 went with the gift of a distaff (a spinning stick) to the wife of his friend Nicias, a doctor of Miletus.2,3
Debated among scholars Not all of it is his. Ancient editors put other country poets into the same books, and later poems came down under his name.3,6 Scholars disagree over which. The 1911 Encyclopaedia Britannica, which Wikipedia still follows, counted Idylls 19, 20, 21, 23 and 25 as spurious;2 Cholmeley rejected 19, 20, 21, 23 and 27;3 Wilamowitz, in his Oxford text of 1905, moved 19–21, 23 and 25–27 to an appendix and judged 8 and 9 not to be his at all.6 Many of the epigrams under his name are doubtful too.2,6 The Syrinx is a puzzle-poem whose answer is a shepherd's pipe dedicated to Pan by Theocritus. A. S. F. Gow argued that it cannot be his, because the pipes of Theocritus' day had reeds of equal length; Edmonds reported the argument, answered it, and kept the poem as Theocritus'.4,13
Songs of herdsmen
The ancient name for this poetry was bucolic, from a Greek verb meaning “to tend cattle”, and LSJ's only example of the word for a “pastoral poet” comes from Idyll 5.15
Idyll 1 sets the pattern. A shepherd, Thyrsis, and a goatherd meet in the pastures at noon. For the gift of a cup, Thyrsis sings how the legendary herdsman Daphnis, stricken by love, wasted away and died, while the gods came one by one to ask what ailed him.2,4 Other poems are singing contests, in which the second singer takes the theme of the first and answers it with a variation of his own.2 The landscape probably reflects Cos, and Theocritus may have drawn on real songs of Sicilian shepherds.17 What made the new form was a mixture: the hexameter, the metre of epic and of the grandest Greek poetry, in the mouths of goatherds speaking the Doric of Sicily.1,17
His Doric Greek
Theocritus wrote most of his poems in Doric, the dialect of his native Sicily, not in the Attic Greek of Athens that learners usually meet first.1,5 The first lines of Idyll 1 show it: «Ἁδύ τι τὸ ψιθύρισμα καὶ ἁ πίτυς αἰπόλε τήνα, ἃ ποτὶ ταῖς παγαῖσι μελίσδεται, ἁδὺ δὲ καὶ τὺ συρίσδες», “Sweet is the whispering of that pine, goatherd, the one that makes its music by the springs; and sweet, too, is your piping” (our translation).18 Where an Athenian would say ἡδύ for “sweet”, ἐκείνη for “that”, πρός for “by” and πηγή for “spring”, the goatherd hears ἁδύ, τήνα, ποτί and παγά: LSJ gives each as the Doric form, and quotes this very line for ψιθύρισμα, “any low whispering noise, as of trees rustling”.15
Theocritus could even make a joke of it. In Idyll 15 a man in the festival crowd loses patience with the two Syracusan women: «παύσασθʼ ὦ δύστανοι, ἀνάνυτα κωτίλλοισαι τρυγόνες. ἐκκναισεῦντι πλατειάσδοισαι ἅπαντα», “Stop it, you poor things, with your endless chatter, turtle-doves! They'll wear everything out with their broad vowels” (our translation). LSJ explains the verb as “pronounce broadly, like the Dorians”.15,19 The answer comes straight back: «Συρακοσίαις ἐπιτάσσεις;», “Is it Syracusan women you are giving orders to?”, and then «Πελοποννασιστὶ λαλεῦμες· δωρίσδεν δʼ ἔξεστι δοκῶ τοῖς Δωριέεσσι», “We talk Peloponnesian; Dorians may speak Doric, I should think” (our translation).15,19
Reading him
He is not easy. Cholmeley called his Greek “naturally difficult”, made harder by his place “at the beginning of a new epoch”.3 But the voices are vivid. Idyll 11 turns the monster of Homer's Odyssey into a lovesick giant who finds comfort in song.2 It opens with advice to his friend Nicias, a doctor: «οὐδὲν πὸτ τὸν ἔρωτα πεφύκει φάρμακον ἄλλο», “there is no other medicine for love” than the Muses (our translation).7 At the end the giant scolds himself: «ὦ Κύκλωψ Κύκλωψ, πᾷ τὰς φρένας ἐκπεπότασαι;», “Cyclops, Cyclops, where have your wits flown off to?” (our translation).20
Why he matters
Debated among scholars Ancient readers made him a classic. In the first century BC, probably about 70 BC, the scholar Artemidorus gathered the country poets into one book, with a little poem of welcome: “The country Muses, once scattered, are now all together, in one fold, in one flock” (our translation).3,15 His son Theon wrote the first commentary. Wilamowitz thought that this edition won Theocritus a fame greater than he had in his own lifetime, “above all through Virgil” (our translation).3,6
Virgil's Eclogues, ten pastoral poems in Latin from the troubled years around 40 BC, take Theocritus as their model: Eclogue 2 adapts Idyll 11, Eclogue 3 is mostly based on Idyll 5, and Eclogue 7 on the doubtful Idyll 8.21 Virgil says so himself at the start of his sixth: his Muse, Thalia, Prima Syracosio dignata est ludere uersu, “first deigned to play in Syracusan verse” (our translation).22 The pastoral lived on through antiquity and into the modern world,1 from Edmund Spenser to Alexander Pope's Pastorals (1709) and Matthew Arnold's Thyrsis (1867), which carries the name of the singer of Idyll 1.17,18