Demosthenes was born in Athens in 384 BC and died in 322, and he is widely counted among the greatest orators of all time.1 His father, also called Demosthenes, came from the village of Paeania in the Athenian countryside.1,2 He was a wealthy sword-maker, and he died when his son was a boy.1 In the boy's own words, his father left “an estate of nearly fourteen talents”, a widow, a daughter of five and “a son, myself, aged seven”.3
The guardians helped themselves. When Demosthenes came of age in 366 BC he demanded an account, and in 363–362 he took them to court in three speeches Against Aphobus.1 The court awarded him ten talents, but he got back only part of his inheritance;1 Plutarch says “he was able to recover not even a small fraction of his patrimony”, though he did gain practice and confidence in speaking.4
Making an orator
Ancient tradition / legend The stories of his training are famous, and nobody knows how many are true.1 Plutarch says his first speeches to the people were jeered, his sentences “confused by long periods”. He dug himself an underground study and practised there for months on end, “shaving one side of his head” so that shame would keep him indoors. One rival, Pytheas, scoffed that his arguments “smelt of lamp wicks”.4 Plutarch got the most famous story from Demetrius of Phalerum, who said he had it from Demosthenes himself in old age: to cure his weak speech he practised “taking pebbles in his mouth and then reciting speeches”, and he trained his voice by speaking while running or climbing steep slopes.5 Asked what came first in oratory, another life reports, “he replied Delivery, and what the second, Delivery, and the third, Delivery”.2
Against Philip
He made his first speech to the Assembly in 354 BC, On the Navy-Boards.1 From then on one danger filled his speeches: Philip II of Macedon. In the First Philippic (351–350) he told the Athenians that “for a free people there can be no greater compulsion than shame for their position”. Even if Philip died, he warned, “you will soon raise up a second Philip”, so long as they went on neglecting their affairs.1,6 In 349, when Philip attacked Olynthus, an ally of Athens, the three Olynthiacs urged them to help; Olynthus fell all the same.1
In 346 Athens made peace with Philip, the Peace of Philocrates,7 and Demosthenes sat on the embassy that went to Philip's court with Aeschines and Philocrates.1 Debated among scholars Aeschines, who became his greatest rival,1 later told the court how Demosthenes fared when his turn came to speak before the king: “he suddenly stopped speaking and stood helpless; finally he collapsed completely”.8 It is a story told by a rival, in a lawsuit.
In 343 Demosthenes prosecuted Aeschines in On the False Embassy, and Aeschines was acquitted by thirty votes.1 Plutarch was not even sure there had been a trial: “Whether the speech denouncing the treacherous embassage of Aeschines was delivered or not, is uncertain”.9 In 341 came the Third Philippic,10 with its cry «τεθνάναι δὲ μυριάκις κρεῖττον ἢ κολακείᾳ τι ποιῆσαι Φιλίππου», “Better to die a thousand times than pay court to Philip”.11
Late in 339 Philip marched into central Greece and took the town of Elatea.7 Demosthenes remembered the moment nine years later: “Evening had already fallen when a messenger arrived bringing to the presiding councillors the news that Elatea had been taken”.12 He went as an envoy to Thebes and won the Thebans over to an alliance with Athens.1 That August the allies met Philip at Chaeronea and were crushed.7 Demosthenes fought in the line as an ordinary soldier.1 Plutarch says he “forsook his post, cast away his arms, and ran away most disgracefully”, and that Philip, drunk after the victory, chanted the opening words of Demosthenes' decree as if it were verse: “Demosthenes, son of Demosthenes, of Paeania, thus moves”.13 Yet the Athenians gave him “the honour of pronouncing the eulogy over the men” who had died.13
The crown
In 336 a citizen called Ctesiphon proposed that Athens honour Demosthenes with a golden crown. Aeschines attacked the proposal as illegal, and the case came to court in 330.1,14 Demosthenes' reply, On the Crown, defended his whole career.14 The jury acquitted so decisively that Aeschines “did not get a fifth part of their ballots”, and he left Athens to teach rhetoric in Rhodes and Ionia.15
At the speech's height Demosthenes swears by the dead of the Persian Wars that Athens was right to fight at Chaeronea, even in defeat: «μὰ τοὺς Μαραθῶνι προκινδυνεύσαντας τῶν προγόνων», “I swear it by our forefathers who bore the brunt of warfare at Marathon”.16 The critic known as Longinus singled out this oath. Demosthenes spoke, he says, «καθάπερ ἐμπνευσθεὶς ἐξαίφνης ὑπὸ θεοῦ», “as if suddenly inspired by a god” (our translation).17 Elsewhere Longinus compares Demosthenes to a thunderbolt and Cicero to a fire that spreads everywhere.1,18
Gold, exile and poison
Debated among scholars In 324 Harpalus, who had run off with treasure entrusted to him by Alexander the Great, came to Athens.1 Plutarch tells how Demosthenes admired a golden cup among the treasure and Harpalus said: “For you it will amount to twenty talents”.19 An inquiry by the council of the Areopagus named Demosthenes; he was convicted, fined fifty talents, and escaped into exile.1,19 Whether he really took the money is still argued: George Grote thought him innocent, while Mogens Hansen thinks it likely that he was justly found guilty.1 Leaving Athens, Plutarch says, he complained to Athena of her three most intractable beasts, “the owl, the serpent, and the people”.19
When Alexander died in 323 the Athenians called him home, sending a trireme to fetch him, and paid off his fine by a trick: they gave him the contract to adorn the altar of Zeus the Saviour for fifty talents.19 He did not enjoy his city for long. Antipater crushed the Greek revolt, and on the motion of Demades the Athenians condemned Demosthenes to death.20 He took refuge in the temple of Poseidon on the island of Calauria. When Antipater's man Archias came for him, he asked to write a letter, and, in the story Plutarch takes from Ariston, “he put his pen to his mouth and bit it”; the poison was already working when he walked out past the altar and fell.20 Plutarch knew other versions too: the poison hidden in a cloth, or in a hollow bracelet.20
Some forty years after his death, in the year Gorgias was archon (about 280 BC), Athens set up a bronze statue of him in the market-place, at his nephew Demochares' request,2 with the verses “If thy strength had only been equal to thy purposes, Demosthenes, Never would the Greeks have been ruled by a Macedonian Ares”. Plutarch says those who claim Demosthenes wrote them himself “talk utter nonsense”;20 the Lives of the Ten Orators reports, on the word of Demetrius of Magnesia, that he did.2
At Rome, Demosthenes inspired Cicero's speeches against Mark Antony,1 and Plutarch notes that “Cicero himself entitled his speeches against Antony Philippics”.21 Quintilian ranked him far the first of the Greek orators and paene lex orandi, almost the very standard of oratory.38