Lysias was a professional writer of speeches for the law courts of Athens. He was born probably in the mid-440s BC and died around 380.1,2 Later antiquity counted him among the ten great Attic orators.1 Yet he lived and died without Athenian citizenship, apart from a grant that was soon struck down: he was a metic, which the dictionary defines as an “alien resident in a foreign city”.3 And this outsider's Greek became, for the critic Dionysius, the purest Attic prose of its day.4
A family from Syracuse
His father, Cephalus, came from Syracuse in Sicily. Lysias himself tells the story: “My father Cephalus was induced by Pericles to come to this country, and dwelt in it for thirty years”.5 The Lives of the Ten Orators, an ancient work once credited to Plutarch,6 calls Cephalus a man of great wealth, and adds that some said he had been banished from Syracuse.7 The family made shields. Lysias and his brother Polemarchus had a factory in the Piraeus, the port of Athens, worked by a hundred and twenty skilled slaves.5,8
Plato set the Republic in their home. Socrates goes back with Polemarchus to his house, and says: “there we found Lysias and Euthydemus, the brothers of Polemarchus”; old Cephalus was at home too.9 The scene suggests that Plato knew the family well.8
Debated among scholars When was Lysias born? The Lives and Dionysius of Halicarnassus give a date that works out at 459 BC. That date was probably reckoned back from a story that he went to the new Athenian colony of Thurii, in southern Italy, at fifteen, the colony having been founded in 444.7,8 Most modern scholars put his birth about 445 and his journey to Thurii about 430,1,2 though W. R. M. Lamb, the translator of the reader's English, was still ready to accept the ancient date in 1930.6
At Thurii, the story goes, he studied rhetoric with the Sicilian teachers Tisias and Nicias.7,8 After the Athenian disaster in Sicily in 413, he “was accused of favouring Athens” and expelled with three hundred others.7 In 412 he settled at Athens.6,8
The Thirty
In 404 BC, after Athens lost the war with Sparta, a junta known as the Thirty seized power.8 Lysias tells what happened next in his speech Against Eratosthenes. Theognis and Peison told the Thirty that some of the metics resented the new regime, which gave a fine excuse to seize their money, and ten men were picked for arrest. Lysias was at home entertaining guests when they came. He offered a talent of silver to save his life, but when he opened his chest Peison helped himself to all of it: “three talents of silver, four hundred cyzicenes, a hundred darics and four silver cups”.5 Taken to a friend's house, Lysias knew it had a back way out: “there were three doors for me to pass through, and they all chanced to be open”. He hid with a ship's captain and sailed to Megara the next night.5
Polemarchus was not so lucky. Eratosthenes, one of the Thirty, arrested him in the street, and he “received from the Thirty their accustomed order to drink hemlock”, without a trial. The family was refused a cloak for his funeral, and a man called Melobius pulled the gold earrings from his widow's ears.5
From Megara, Lysias helped the exiled democrats who fought their way back. The Lives says he gave two thousand drachmas and two hundred shields and hired three hundred soldiers.7 When democracy returned in 403, Thrasybulus proposed to make him a citizen. The grant was struck down on a point of procedure, because the Council had not voted on it first.7,8 Lysias lived on as an isoteles, a privileged metic who paid the same taxes as a citizen.3,7
Against Eratosthenes
In 403 Lysias prosecuted Eratosthenes for his brother's death. It was his only direct part in Athenian politics.8 The speech ends with four words and a command: «ἀκηκόατε, ἑωράκατε, πεπόνθατε, ἔχετε· δικάζετε», “You have heard, you have seen, you have suffered; you have them: give judgement.”10 Debated among scholars Did he speak it himself? Its title in the manuscripts says so, and Lamb saw no reason to doubt it.6 Stephen Todd, whose commentary on the speech is the largest in English, thinks it unclear whether a non-citizen could take part in this kind of hearing. He leaves open that the speech was circulated as a pamphlet instead.11
Speeches for hire
Much of his fortune had been seized, and probably for that reason, among others, Lysias turned to writing speeches for clients to deliver in court.2,8 He became a logographos, a “professional speech-writer”.3 It was not a respected trade: in Plato's Phaedrus a politician abuses Lysias and “kept calling him a speech-writer”, «λογογράφον».12 His career ran from 403 to about 380.2 The Lives says: “Four hundred and twenty-five orations attributed to him are current”. Ancient critics accepted 233 of them as genuine, and with those “he is said to have lost his case with only two of them”.7
Ancient tradition / legend Plutarch tells a story about one client. The man read his speech over and over and came back in despair: the first time it seemed wonderful, but by the third reading it was “completely dull and ineffectual”. Lysias laughed: “isn’t it only once that you are going to speak it before the jurors?”13
Today the most widely read of his speeches, at least by students, is probably On the Murder of Eratosthenes (a different Eratosthenes).11 An Athenian called Euphiletus caught a man named Eratosthenes in bed with his wife, killed him, and was put on trial for murder.2,6 He paints himself as a trusting husband, “simple-minded enough to suppose that my own was the chastest wife in the city”.14 Lysias wrote speeches for the Council, the Assembly and the courts, and showpieces too.4 At the Olympic festival of 388, the date given by the historian Diodorus, he called on the Greeks to unite against Dionysius, the tyrant of Syracuse.7,8 Debated among scholars Some historians have preferred 384, but Lamb thought the speech itself points to 388.1,6 The opening of that speech survives because Dionysius of Halicarnassus quoted it: Lysias deplores a Greece “with many parts of her held subject by the foreigner, and many of her cities ravaged by despots”.15,16 His latest datable work belongs to 381 or 380, and he probably died in or soon after 380.8
The plain style
Dionysius of Halicarnassus, a Greek teacher of rhetoric at Rome in the reign of Augustus,17 wrote a whole essay on Lysias.4,6 He calls his language pure, «τῆς Ἀττικῆς γλώττης ἄριστος κανών», “the best standard of the Attic tongue” (our translation): not the older Attic of Plato and Thucydides, but the Attic spoken in his own time. No later writer, he says, surpassed him in purity. Lysias uses ordinary words and hardly any figures of speech, yet makes his subjects seem grand.4 He also praises the quality that many called «ἠθοποιΐαν»: the drawing of character, so that each speech sounds like the person who delivers it.3,18 Lysias' sentences seem artless, but, says Dionysius, «πεποίηται γὰρ αὐτῷ τοῦτο τὸ ἀποίητον», “this very artlessness is something he has made” (our translation).18 The Lives puts it in one line: “In the matter of his diction he appears to be easy, although in fact he is hard to imitate.”7
Ancient critics spoke of three styles, the grand, the middle and the plain, and Lysias became the model of the plain, the one nearest to everyday speech.8 The Roman teacher Quintilian admired his subtlety and elegance, but “would compare him to a clear spring rather than to a mighty river”.19
Lysias in Plato
Plato's Phaedrus opens with Phaedrus coming from a morning with Lysias, the son of Cephalus, full of a speech on love that Lysias has written; Socrates guesses that he has the text hidden under his cloak. Phaedrus calls Lysias “the cleverest writer of our day”, «δεινότατος ὢν τῶν νῦν γράφειν».20 Socrates answers with speeches of his own, and Phaedrus admits that Socrates' was far finer. Socrates prays that Love will turn Lysias, “as his brother Polemarchus is turned, toward philosophy”.12 At the end he predicts that the young Isocrates “has a nature above the speeches of Lysias”.21 Debated among scholars Is the love speech in the Phaedrus really by Lysias? It has generally been thought Plato's own work, but Jebb pointed out how carefully the dialogue insists on an exact reading of it.8 Lamb thought it more probably a Platonic parody.6
Ancient tradition / legend The Lives lists among his writings “a Defence of Socrates addressed to the judges”.7 Diogenes Laertius tells how Socrates read the speech Lysias wrote for him and said: “A fine speech, Lysias; it is not, however, suitable to me.” Asked why not, he answered that fine clothes and shoes would not suit him either.22 Jebb thought the story probably arose from a confusion: years after Socrates' death the sophist Polycrates wrote a speech attacking him, and Lysias replied.8