“There was a man in the army named Xenophon, an Athenian, who was neither general nor captain nor private”: that is how Xenophon walks into his own story, at the start of the third book of the Anabasis. He had come along, he says, because an old friend, Proxenus, had invited him and promised to make him a friend of the Persian prince Cyrus.1 Before the chapter is over the soldiers have chosen him as one of their generals: “Xenophon the Athenian in place of Proxenus”.2
He was born about 430 BC in Erchia, one of the country districts of Athens, the son of Gryllus.3,4,5 Soldier, exile, landowner and follower of Socrates, he wrote fourteen books of very different kinds, and every one of them survives: history, memoir, conversations of Socrates, a partly invented life of a Persian king, and handbooks on horses, hunting and money.4,29
A pupil of Socrates
Ancient tradition / legend Diogenes Laertius tells how they met. Socrates stopped the young man in a narrow passage, barred the way with his stick and asked where each kind of food was sold; then he asked, “where do men become good and honourable?” Xenophon had no answer. “Then follow me, said Socrates, and learn.”5
Diogenes also calls him “the first to take notes of, and to give to the world, the conversation of Socrates”, in the Memorabilia.5 The Anabasis shows the two men together. When Proxenus' letter came, Xenophon asked Socrates' advice. Socrates feared that friendship with Cyrus, who had helped Sparta in its war against Athens, might be held against him at home, and told him to put the question to Apollo at Delphi. Xenophon asked the god only which gods he should sacrifice to for a safe journey. Socrates scolded him for making up his mind first and asking afterwards, but told him to do what the god had said.1
Socrates was tried and put to death at Athens in 399 BC,6 while Xenophon was far away: Diogenes dates the march to the year before Socrates died.7
Xenophon's Socratic books defend his teacher. The Memorabilia opens: “I have often wondered by what arguments those who drew up the indictment against Socrates could persuade the Athenians that his life was forfeit to the state.”8 It closes with a portrait: “For myself, I have described him as he was”.9 In his Apology he says that others had already written about Socrates' defence, and he leans on the reports of Hermogenes, a companion of Socrates.10 His Symposium tells of a dinner party as “an experience of mine”,11 and in the Oeconomicus Socrates talks about how to run an estate.12
The march of the Ten Thousand
In 401 BC Cyrus the Younger marched inland to take the Persian throne from his brother, Artaxerxes II, with an army of Greek mercenaries.13 When the army was reviewed, Xenophon reports, the Greeks numbered 10,400 hoplites (armoured infantry) and 2,500 lighter-armed peltasts.14 At the battle of Cunaxa, near Babylon, Cyrus was killed, and the expedition lost its point.13,15 Soon afterwards the Greek generals were seized by treachery and beheaded before the King.13,16
Stranded, the army chose new leaders, Xenophon among them,2 and fought its way north through mountains and snow towards the Black Sea.13 The most famous scene comes on a mountain called Theches. A great shout goes up at the front. Xenophon, with the rearguard, thinks enemies are attacking, rides forward, and hears the soldiers shouting «θάλαττα θάλαττα», “The Sea! The Sea!” They embrace one another, generals and captains too, in tears, and pile up a great cairn of stones.17
The march ended in 399 BC, when the Spartan commander Thibron took over the army.3,18
Sparta, Scillus and exile
Xenophon went on serving with the Spartans, and when King Agesilaus went home to fight in Greece he went too. At Coronea, in 394 BC, he fought against his fellow Athenians.4 Plutarch says the same: Xenophon “was present himself and fought on the side of Agesilaüs, having crossed over with him from Asia”.19 Agesilaus made much of him, and told him to send for his sons and bring them up at Sparta.20
Debated among scholars When and why Athens exiled him is not clear. At the end of the march, he says, “not yet had sentence of exile been pronounced against him at Athens”.21 Pausanias gives the reason as his part in Cyrus' expedition, since Cyrus was the enemy of the Athenian people;22 Diogenes says it was for siding with Sparta.23 Whether Coronea caused the exile or came after it is disputed; that he was exiled is not.4
The Spartans settled him at Scillus, near Olympia. There, with money set aside for Artemis of Ephesus, he bought land for the goddess and built her a small copy of her temple at Ephesus, with a statue of cypress wood where Ephesus had gold. Every year he held a festival for the neighbours, with hunting in the sacred grounds.24 Diogenes says that at Scillus he “hunted, entertained his friends, and worked at his histories”.23 He stayed more than twenty years, until the collapse of Spartan power in 371 BC drove him to Corinth.4,7
Debated among scholars The people of Elis told a different ending. Their guides said that Xenophon was tried for taking the land, was pardoned, and lived on at Scillus in safety; near the sanctuary they showed Pausanias a tomb with a marble statue, which the neighbours said was Xenophon's.22
In the end Xenophon and Athens made peace. When Athens voted to help Sparta, he sent his sons to serve, Diogenes says,7 and his son Gryllus died fighting as an Athenian cavalryman at Mantinea in 362 BC.4
Ancient tradition / legend Xenophon was sacrificing, a garland on his head, when the news came. He took the garland off, and put it back on when he heard that his son had died gloriously. Some said he did not even weep, but said: “I knew my son was mortal.”7
Diogenes also reports a story that one decree of Eubulus banished him and another recalled him;25 whether he ever went home to live is not known.4 He died, Diogenes says, at Corinth, “obviously at an advanced age”.25 Most modern scholars put his death in 355 or 354 BC.3
Every kind of book
Xenophon wrote fourteen works, and all of them survive.4 Diogenes lists them and counts “some forty books in all”, since several of the works run to more than one book.25
History. The Hellenica takes up the story where Thucydides breaks off, in 411 BC, and carries it down to 362.26 It has no preface of its own, and simply begins «μετὰ δὲ ταῦτα», “After this”.26,27 It ends with the battle of Mantinea, which left Greece in more confusion than before, and a shrug: “Thus far be it written by me; the events after these will perhaps be the concern of another.”28
Memoir. The Anabasis, the march of the Ten Thousand, told with Xenophon in the third person.13
A life that is partly fiction. The Cyropaedia, The Education of Cyrus, is a partly fictional life of Cyrus the Great, founder of the Persian empire.29 It sets out to learn how one man could rule so many peoples who “obeyed Cyrus willingly”.30 Herodotus has Cyrus fall in battle against the Massagetae, and their queen, Tomyris, push his dead head into a skin full of blood;31 Xenophon's Cyrus dies an old man in Persia, after a farewell to his sons and friends: he “covered himself over, and so died”.32
Rulers and Sparta. Agesilaus, in praise of the Spartan king;4 the Constitution of the Lacedaemonians; and Hiero, on tyranny.25
Handbooks. On horsemanship, on the duties of a cavalry commander, on hunting, and Ways and Means, a plan to mend Athens' finances, with a chapter on getting more out of the silver mines.25,33 Ways and Means was written in 355 BC and is thought to be his last work.34 On Horsemanship begins politely by naming an older book on the subject by a man called Simon.35
Ancient readers loved the way he wrote. “By the sweetness of his narrative he earned the name of the Attic Muse”, says Diogenes: «Ἀττικὴ Μοῦσα».25
Ancient tradition / legend Diogenes adds two stories: that Xenophon and Plato were jealous of each other, and that Xenophon “made Thucydides famous by publishing his history, which was unknown”, when he could have passed it off as his own.25
Later readers
In the second century AD the historian Arrian37 remarked, early in his own history of Alexander the Great, that the march of the Ten Thousand, and the retreat Xenophon led, were far better known than Alexander's deeds, thanks to Xenophon.36 Arrian imitated Xenophon more than any other model, and was himself called Xenophon.38 His own book on hunting sets out to fill the gaps in Xenophon's, as a man with the same name, the same city and the same loves: hunting, generalship and wisdom.39
The Cyropaedia had famous readers. The Roman general Scipio Aemilianus is said to have carried a copy with him at all times, and it was a favourite of Alexander the Great and Julius Caesar. In the late Middle Ages and the Renaissance it shaped the mirrors for princes, books of advice for rulers, and Machiavelli's The Prince.29
The Anabasis, in its clear and plain Attic Greek, has long been one of the first complete texts that students of Greek read.13 Over the twentieth century Xenophon faded from school courses and scholarly journals alike; then, in the 1990s and 2000s, Xenophon studies boomed.40